History of the Restoration Movement

Tolbert Fanning


The Life of Tolbert Fanning

Tolbert Fanning was born in Cannon County, Tennessee on May 10, 1810. He was the son of William and Nancy Bromley Fanning. Not much is known of his early years, but in about 1818 the family moved to Lauderdale County, in Alabama's most northwest section. There, he attended a school on Cypress Creek, operated by Ross Houston, the brother of Alabama Governor George S. Houston (1808-1879). By 1824, the Christian movement was established on the creek, with James E. Matthews and Ephraim D. Moore leading the group.

In the fall of 1826, a young preacher by the name of B.F. Hall came into the region teaching a doctrine of salvation, different to what they had been preaching. He taught that the gospel must be obeyed, and that when they were baptized, they would be relieved of the guilt of their sins. While preaching one night, the sixteen-year-old, Tolbert Fanning, responded to the invitation. The following morning, October 1st, James Matthews baptized him for the forgiveness of his sins in Cypress Creek.

Within three years, Tolbert Fanning was preaching occasionally in different locations. He was passionate about his beliefs, and was greatly desirous of opportunities to share the gospel. On one occasion early in his ministry, he was in Murfreesboro, Tennessee, where he witnessed a brother selling one of his black slaves, who was also a Christian. Fanning had, early in life, been convinced that the institution of slavery was ungodly. The following day, he preached at the East Main St. church of Christ on the ungodly practice of slavery in America. His preaching was met with great anger by most of the church. It was agreed that Tolbert Fanning would never preach for that church again. The year was 1830; thirty-one years before the country would be embroiled in civil war over the issue.

The following year, he had his first debate in Nashville, Tennessee with the local Presbyterian minister, Obadiah Jennings. Jennings had debated Alexander Campbell a couple of years earlier. The subject was on baptism.

Fanning moved to Nashville in January of 1832, where he entered the University of Nashville, in search of a law degree. The following summer, he went to Kentucky, and traveled with Alexander Campbell through the state, preaching and evangelizing. He graduated at the end of the school year, 1835. During the summer, he traveled through Kentucky again with Alexander Campbell. In the fall, he married Sarah Shreve of Nicholasville, Kentucky. They were married, but three days later she was overcome with a fatal illness. Twelve days later, she went to be with the Lord. Though deeply grieved, he continued to preach throughout the region. The following year, he married English born, Charlotte Fall. As a side note, she was the sister of Philip S. Fall, a gospel preacher who, preaching for the Baptist Church in Nashville in the mid-1820s, converted the whole congregation to New Testament Christianity, and thus organized the church of Christ in that city. Tolbert was twenty-six and Charlotte was twenty-seven when they were married.

With the marriage of Tolbert and Charlotte Fanning, education of young people quickly became their life's greatest passions. Between 1837 and 1839, they conducted a female academy in Franklin, Tennessee. Later, in 1840, they moved to Elm Crag, in southeast Nashville, (the property is now the location of the international airport). Immediately, they opened another female academy that continued for another two years. In 1843, they expanded their operations to include a boys agricultural school that continued for two years. The school was unique, in that the students earned their education through daily working a farm.

Perhaps, the Fannings are best known for establishing Franklin College. Beginning in January 1845, this college was where men like William and David Lipscomb, Elisha G. Sewell, and T.B. Larimore received their training. The school continued until the beginning of the Civil War, when all the students left to join the Confederate Army. The school resumed in the fall of 1865, only to have the main building burn to the ground a few weeks into the term. Providentially, a girl's college that existed just a few hundred yards from Franklin College was purchased. The school became known as Hope Institute. Franklin College began conducting classes at Hope Institute and continued several years.

In addition to being an educator, Tolbert Fanning was a writer. He enjoyed a wide range of research, and it translated into writing in a number of different fields of interest. His interest in farming and raising cattle led him to edit a paper called the Agriculturalist from 1840-1845. It served as the official journal of the Tennessee state agricultural association. He also edited a religious paper called the Christian Review from 1844-1847. However, the magazine he is best known for is a paper he began in 1855 called the Gospel Advocate. Other than a few years during the Civil War, the paper has continued for over 150 years, and perhaps has been the single greatest influence in the churches of Christ in the southern United States. Subsequent editors of the magazine involve a veritable who's who in restoration history, some of which were David Lipscomb, H. Leo Boles, B.C. Goodpasture, Guy N. Woods, F. Furman Kearley and Neil Anderson. Today the magazine continues under the editorship of Greg Tidwell, and the paper is still a strong voice for Scriptural soundness. Everyone should subscribe to and read the Gospel Advocate.

In the spring of 1874, Fanning suffered an accident when a prize bull gored the six-foot, six-inch farmer/preacher. He was immediately put to bed. After a week or two, he began to get out of bed and walk around the property again. During one walk, he over-exerted himself, feeling a tear inside. He went back to bed, never to rise again. The following Sunday morning, May 3rd, at 11:30 am, he passed away. Today his remains lie in the family plot in Mt. Olivet Cemetery in Nashville. Only eternity will reveal the great good that has been done for the cause of Christ by Tolbert and Charlotte Fanning.

-Scott Harp, 06.2011, updated 04.2020.

Chronology On The Life Of Tolbert Fanning

Parents of Tolbert, William And Nancy Bromley Fanning marry

1809 - April 10
Charlotte Fall is born near London, England to a prominent family. She later becomes Tolbert's second wife

1810 - May 10
Birth of Tolbert Fanning in Cannon County, Tennessee

Charlotte Fall moved with her family from London, England to Logan County, Ky. Her mother dies shortly after their arrival, and father soon followed, leaving Philip S. Fall, her older brother, to raise she and her siblings (10 in all)

Family moves to Lauderdale County, Alabama

Andrew Jackson (A.J.), brother of Tolbert was born

1826 - Oct. 1
Baptized by James Matthews after hearing the preaching of B.F. Hall on Cypress Creek, Lauderdale County, Alabama

1829 - Oct. 1
Left home to begin preaching. Area of early work: Tenn. and Ala./19 yrs old.

Preached sermon rebuking Christian slaveholder, who had broken up a family by selling slave. Arrested, tried, and acquitted.

Early preaching in Alabama and Tennessee.

Has a debate with Obadiah Jennings, the preacher of the Presbyterian church in Nashville. (A. Campbell had debated him in 1829). Hazzard, p.30

1831 - Oct. 1
Begins preaching full-time

1832 - January
Entered University of Nashville.

1832 - Summer
Tolbert travels with A. Campbell on tour thru Ohio & Kentucky

1832 - August
Baptizes 17 in Franklin County, Tenn. Begins church there

Graduated From University of Nashville

Accompanied Alexander Campbell on preaching tour thru Kentucky and other points east. — Spent extensive time with John T. Johnson — In Perryville, Ky, he conducted his first debate with a Methodist minister named Rice (not N.L. Rice)

1835 - Fall
Made trip to and preached around Georgetown, Kentucky.

1835 - November 5
Marries Sarah Shreve daughter of land owner, William Shreve of Nicholasville, Kentucky

1835 - November 8
Sarah comes down with a fatal illness.

1835 - November 20
Sarah Fanning dies.

1836 - February
Visits John R. Howard at Paris, TN after a trip to Mississippi. Preaches to large crowds each evening. So large meetings had to be moved to the courthouse. "Three confessed and were baptized for the remission of sins." John R. Howard, Christian Reformer.

1836 - May
94 Day trip accompanying Campbell on longer tour through Western Reserve of Ohio, New England states, and into Canada. Fanning delivered address in Boston which was published as tract. Visited Campbell's home at Bethany, Va. (Campbell was 55 yrs, and Fanning was 26)

Wrote that he estimated the church of Christ to have 100,000 members.

1836 - Dec. 22
Married English born, Charlotte Fall, sister of P. S. Fall. Friend Philip Lindsley, teacher at University of Nashville presides. (Tolbert is 26 years old, Charlotte is 27) (J.E. Choate reported that it was December 25th, GA 2005, 07.34)

Established "Female Academy" at Franklin, Tenn.

Establishes a church in Jackson, Mississippi

1839 - October
In Nashville, meets with fellow agriculturalists, organizing the Tennessee Agricultural Society. Becomes its first recording secretary. Begins editing a paper of the society called, The Agriculturalist

1840 - Jan. 1
Moved to farm, Elm Crag, near Nashville.

1840 - January
Opened a school for girls, similar to one in Franklin — continued for two years

Debate with Edward McMillon, Presbyterian.

1840 - Aug. 18
Formed with other agriculturalists and mayor of Nashville a Silk Society.

He teaches a Female Seminary (Ecclectic Institute for Young Ladies) at Elm Crag.

Editor of Agriculturalist, official journal of the state agricultural society, which Fanning had helped found. Franklin, p.22 (Note: Hazzard p.58 says he edited the paper nearly six years

1841 - Oct. 14,15
At the state fair, he took first place cups for his heifer calf and bull calf, as well as his stallion—Cleveland Bay

1842 - February
Planted church in Russellville, Alabama — Over 100 baptisms. During 6 month tour that took them into Columbus, Miss. and other places, over 200 were baptized all together.
Participated in first "cooperation meeting" held in Tenn. Continued to support such meetings through the 1840's

1843 - January
Started an agricultural school for boys at Elm Crag with 12 students (continues thru 1844)

He estimated the church of Christ to have 300,000 members

1843 - June
2nd Debate with Edward McMillon, in Moulton, Alabama

1843 - Summer
Debated N. L. Rice, Presbyterian, in Nashville, (He regretted debating him, as he felt Rice was doing it just to ready himself for the Campbell debate later in the year in Lexington, Ky.

1844-47 - January
Began publishing monthly religious journal, Christian Review. (W.H. Wharton & J. C. Anderson were initally co-editors) (Christian Review, Vol. 1, #2, February, 1844, page 48.) In second year, Jesse B. Ferguson assisted in the paper. Hazzard, p65.

Made a tour to eastern states. All the way to Boston, Mass. then back through to Cincinnati, OH., thru Kentucky and home

Established Franklin College at Elm Crag. College continued in operation until outbreak of Civil War. Average attendance: 100-130.
A.J. Fanning, Tolbert's brother was first graduate of Franklin College with B.A. Later would come back to teach at college
D.S. Burnett starts the Bible Society, and Fanning gives support to it

January 1, 1846
New paper started, The Naturalist, in Nashville. It was a science mag. Tolbert was the editor of the Agriculture section. Hazzard p.59

National Committee for evangelism appointed

1847 - November
Last Issue of Christian Review

Christian Review superseded by Christian Magazine, edited by Jesse Ferguson (co-editors were B.F. Hall & T. Fanning) Yet in the life-time of the paper he only contributed 6 articles.

Endorsed Cincinnati meeting which organized American Christian Missionary Society (October 23). Did not attend Cincinnati meeting.

1850 - December
Debated Mr. Chapman, Methodist, in Lebanon, Tennessee — 5 day discussion

Helped organize Tennessee Evangelizing Association (a state missionary society). Served as its first Corresponding Secretary.

New Nashville church building completed

After April issue of Christian Magazine, Jesse Ferguson became involved in bitter controversy with Campbell. Results: (1) Ferguson left church and went into Spiritualism and Universalism,(2) church in Nashville was nearly destroyed.

1855 - July
Began publication of Gospel Advocate, with William Lipscomb as co-editor. Opposed missionary societies. Gradually brought majority of Tennessee churches to this point of view.

Enters controversy with Robert Richardson
Nashville church building burns — Ferguson parties blamed

Delivered address at 10th annual American Christian Missionary Society convention in Cincinnati. Declared that Tenn. churches opposed Society, but added, "We are one people."

Outbreak of Civil War. Fanning opposed Christians' participation.

1861 - October
American Christian Missionary Society adopted resolution favoring the North. Fanning was embittered, and it appeared in writing in the November issue of GA

1861 - November
Last Issue of Gospel Advocate until after Civil War

Gospel Advocate & Franklin College Interrupted

Drafted appeal to President of Confederacy requesting that members of churches of Christ be exempt from military service.

1865 - August
Home of Tolbert Fanning burns to the ground

1865 - Oct. 2
Franklin College Re-opens — within a few weeks the main building burns destroying everything, including W.D. Carnes' library ($30-$40 thousand worth in flames (not insured)

Gospel Advocate resumed publication. David Lipscomb: co-editor. Fanning led in calling a "consultation meeting" of southern Christians to survey condition of church following Civil War. Refused to invite northern Christians. Wanted no "hasty religious reconstruction."

1866 - December
Hope Institute Chartered after school burns.

Charter obtained for Peace College

1868 - July 3
Last tour to Alabama and Mississippi

1872 - January
Attended a debate in Gallatin, Tn between David Lipscomb and Baptist G.W. Griffin

Began the Religious Historian, Hazzard, p75

1873 - December
Attended a debate in Franklin, Tn between T.W. Brents and Methodist, Jacob Ditzler

Published Religious Historian

1874 - May 3
Died after attacked by bull a few weeks earlier. His brother-in-law Philip S. Fall, preached his funeral the next day. Buried under the protective trees of Hope Institute

Franklin = Franklin College and its Influences, ed. James E. Scobey, c.1954, Gospel Advocate Company
Hazzard = Hazzard of the Dye, James R. Wilburn, c.1969, R.B. Sweet, Co., Inc.

Tolbert Fanning Historical Marker

In the summer of 2003 a historical marker was set up on the property where Franklin College once stood, where the Fannings were originally buried. It is now land used for Nashville's International Airport. However the beautiful marker located on the southeast corner of Vultee Blvd. & Briley Pkwy. (Hwy 155) is a tribute to the work of Tolbert and Charlotte Fanning. I visited this site with David Decker August 7, 2003 while returning to Atlanta from Henderson, where we paid respect to the family of the late Dowell Flatt.

GPS Coordinates Of Historical Marker
Accuracy To Within 17'
Facing North

View Larger Map

Tolbert Fanning

In 1844, noted educator, evangelist,
and agriculturist Tolbert Fanning
started Franklin College, a liberal
arts school near this site where boys
farmed to cover tuition. In 1855 he
co-founded the Gospel Advocate, a
religious journal. Fanning's wife,
Charlotte Fall, began Fanning Orphan
School for girls in 1884. Their aim
was to put education within
the "reach of every youth."

This Was Erected By The Historical Commission Of Metropolitan Nashville And Davidson County
No. 113; Erected 2003

Located At The SE Cnr. of Vultee Blvd. & Briley Pkwy, Nashville, Tennessee

Lines to the Memory of Eld. T. Fanning

A deep, and saddening sound awoke,
The slumbering midnight air,
Through forest depths, the echo broke,
And mourning deep is there—
A mighty Oak, is lying low,
The forest trembles, 'neath the blow.

A vacant post on Zion's wall,
No other form may fill
A watch-man gone, whose warning voice
Was heard from hill to hill,
A soldier, tried and true, and brave
Now sleeps, but fills a victor's grave!

Dear Zion mourns, a leader gone,
A chieftain, faithful, true,
A vigilant, whose watchful eye
Kept every post in view,
The wiley foe,—the danger nigh,
Still met his ever sleepless eye.

He fought, still near his captains side,
And kept his armor bright,
And firmly held the "blood-stained" flag
Amidst the thickest fight,
His clarion voice, with trumpet tone,
Still sounded, "Honor God Alone."

No title'd honors, did he boast,
His power, was, "Truth Divine"
The "two-edged sword" his conquering host
The "Cross" his only shrine—
His victory's banner floating wide,
Bear only this, "the crucified."

The trembling hosts of Babel fled,
Before the "two-edged blade"
As on and onward still he sped.
And all its power display'd
The Law of Heaven, his battle cry,
On, soldiers on, to victory!

While loving-laurels, wreath'd his brow,
And shouts of victory came,
He calmly laid his armor by,
And bless'd his captain's name—
That name, so dear in life, in death
He honored with his dying breath.

Now folded on his peaceful breast,
Those active hands lie still,
And weeping friends are waiting now,
Sad duties to fulfil,
One true, deep mourner, lingers there,
No other heart, her grief may share.

We bow, and bless, thy cherished name
O, dear departed one!
And gratefully remember all
Thy loving heart has done,
The orphans tears, for thee shall flow
Their dearest, truest friend below.

But never, never shall we hear
Thy blessed voice again,
To higher notes, in brighter sphere,
‘Twill strike a loftier strain,
And still thy works will follow thee
And ages tell of victory,

Our mourning hearts would say Farewell,
And drop a grateful tear,
Eternity alone may tell
Thy glorious record here,
Thy crown, in that bright land afar,
Shall shine with many a brilliant star.

-Mrs. M.S. Fanning
(widowed sister-in-law of T. Fanning)
Lone Star, Texas
Gospel Advocate, August 13, 1874, p. 763-764

Three Burial Locations

Initially, the final resting place of Tolbert Fanning was on the back of the old Elm Crag property where the home and Franklin College existed, at the southwest corner of Briley Parkway and Vultee Pike. See Historical Marker. Twenty-two years later Charlotte died, and his body was exhumed and buried with his wife at the front of the property. In 1940, the Airport Authority in Nashville purchased the property. Today one of the airport runways of the International Airport lays on top of the old farm and campus.

Tolbert and Charlotte Fall Fanning are now buried in the Mt. Olivet Cemetery, Nashville Tennessee. The cemetery is located at 1101 Lebanon Pike, Southeast of downtown Nashville. Click over to Mt. Olivet for map and location of the grave in the cemetery. This is the third location for the remains of Tolbert Fanning and the second for Charlotte. They are buried in Section 25 - Lot #56. Be sure to see map for directions in the cemetery. MAP

GPS Coordinates
Accuracy To Within 16'
Facing North

View Larger Map

The Setting At Mt. Olivet Cemetery

Charlotte Fall Fanning


The sister of Philip S. Fall, Charlotte was the second wife of Tolbert Fanning. She was a very intelligent Christian woman, who believed in education. She and her husband, Tolbert were one of the greatest known husband/wife teams of the Restoration Movement. One prized book in my collection is The Life Of Charlotte Fall Fanning, written by Emma Page, who was the wife of T.B. Larimore. (T.B.L. was one of the Fanning's students at Franklin College.) It was a brief biography on her life, but also recorded articles that Charlotte had written. Both Charlotte and Tolbert are buried in the same grave.

Borne April 10.1809 Died August 15, 1896
"She Spent Her Life In Training Girls For Usefulness And In Doing
Good She Founded A School In Which Girls Would Be Taught The
Bible Daily, And Trained In The Domestic And Useful Callings Of Life.
'I Was Sick And You Visited Me.' By Her Neighbors


Born May 10, 1810 Died May 3, 1874

Two Objects Were Near His Heart - First, To Restore The Service

Of God To The Order God Gave In The New Testament. Second, To

Place A Good, Industrial And Literary Education Within Reach

Of Every Youth. He Labored To These Ends During His Life, And

Desired His Property Devoted To Them After His Death.

See Four Biographical Sketches On Tolbert Fanning

Another Sketch On The Life Of Charlotte Fall Fanning

History Home

History Index Page

Copyright © 2024, Scott Harp. All rights reserved.